Quiet Picks

A QUIET TOOL

The cost-per-year calculator

Every record in this library is judged by one plain number: not the sticker, but the price divided by the years a thing is kept. Here it is for whatever you are weighing — the durable thing you would keep against the cheap one you would replace.

The thing you'd keep
$
$
The thing you'd replace
$

Over the same span you keep the durable one, how many of these would you buy? The calculator counts them.

Kept

$1.33 / year

Replaced

$5.00 / year

Cumulative spend (approx. — upkeep prorated per year)
AfterKeptReplaced
3 years
5 years
10 years

Nothing you type leaves your browser. The arithmetic runs on this page alone; "copy a link" simply puts your numbers in the URL so you can return to them.

What the number does not say

Cost per year is the floor of the argument, not the whole of it. A thing also has to be repairable, made by someone likely to still exist, and worth keeping at all — the three questions behind every record. The calculator tells you which purchase is cheaper across its life; the catalog tells you which is worth that life.

And when the thing is already yours and the question is a repair quote, the same arithmetic has its own page: the repair-or-replace calculator.

For things already worked out this way, the shelves where the numbers tend to favour keeping: